Friday, April 2, 2010
Hughes vs. Cullen
In response to Emily's post on the comparison between Hughes and Cullen, I too can see the distinct differences between the writing and idealogies of Hughes and Cullen. While Hughes sticks to his roots, and is proud to be of African descent, Cullen wants to push his association with Africa far behind him, as if he is ashamed of where he came from. To me, these two stances seem very extreme. For Hughes, I can understand the desire to be proud of who you are, but the only subject he is writing about is being black. This gets quite repetitive and will not gain the respect he probably would of wanted from other poets, both black and white. While Cullen, on the other hand, doesn't want to be who he is. This is also hard to respect and understand. Although there are rough circumstances in his way, I feel you should never wear a mask or pretend you are something you are not. If a middle ground could be found between these two poets, I think that poet would be very successful and interesting to read.
Becky
Referencing Wednesday's class, I one piece that I thought was interesting was Arna Bontemp's "Becky," which has an interesting connection with Harriet Wilson's "Our Nig." In "Becky" we learn about the persecution of a white woman, Becky who has two black children. Similarly in "Our Nig" the audience becomes aware of Old Mag who marries a black man and has children as well. Although one is fictional and the other autobiographical, one can see the similarities through white society's perception of a relationship between a white woman and a black man. In "Becky" the reader is enticed through a neutral narrator, but he or she intentional illustrates the town's curiosity with Becky through a white perspective. On the other hand, Old Mag is depicted through the eyes of her abandoned child, which influences the narrator's perception of her mother. Something that is new in "Becky" is the fear instilled in society through her supposed death, which the narrator believes will happen through her return as a ghost. I find this striking because although people don't respect Becky, they fear her because of their behavior towards her. This leads me to believe that white society did know what they were doing and even though they knew it was wrong continued to look down upon Becky and her family. I find myself frustrated by the lack of morals that white society had because even though they knew what they were doing was wrong, they continued their persecution of Becky.
Relationship between Mrs. Ellsworth and Oceola
Hey everyone! In this week’s readings, I found Langston Hughes’ short story “The Blues I’m Playing” very interesting. Also, I felt that it was in some ways, similar to James Weldon Johnson’s “The Autobiography of an Ex-Colored Man”. In both stories, I feel as though the black, less-fortunate character is being manipulated by the non-colored, wealthy character. In both pieces of literature, the non-colored character is controlling and manipulating the actions of the non-colored character. In “The Blues I’m Playing”, on many occasions, Mrs. Ellsworth tries to control and dictate Oceola’s life and decisions. For example, Mrs. Ellsworth tries to convince Oceola to move out of her little flat and away from her roomer Pete Williams. Mrs. Ellsworth feels as though “the poor child [Oceola] is being preyed upon” and therefore, she must “get her out of Harlem at once.” (1318). I also found it very surprising how much Mrs. Ellsworth believed that art could replace love and relationships. For example, she says that Oceola “won’t need him [Pete Williams]. She will have her art” (1318). I was however very surprised to see that Oceola did not let Mrs. Ellsworth sway her decision to marry Pete.
My question for you all is whether or not you feel as though Mrs. Ellsworth (or in the case of Johnson, the millionaire) truly cared for Oceola’s development as a black individual or if she had a hidden agenda. It was very nice and generous of Mrs. Ellsworth to pay for so many things for Oceola however I wonder what Mrs. Ellsworth “intentions” truly were. Maybe they really were genuine. Maybe Mrs. Ellsworth simply wanted a better life for Oceola. Or maybe, she wanted Oceola to change into someone more like her. What do you guys think? Do you feel as though Mrs. Ellsworth allowed Oceola to live her own life or do you think she was too controlling?
My question for you all is whether or not you feel as though Mrs. Ellsworth (or in the case of Johnson, the millionaire) truly cared for Oceola’s development as a black individual or if she had a hidden agenda. It was very nice and generous of Mrs. Ellsworth to pay for so many things for Oceola however I wonder what Mrs. Ellsworth “intentions” truly were. Maybe they really were genuine. Maybe Mrs. Ellsworth simply wanted a better life for Oceola. Or maybe, she wanted Oceola to change into someone more like her. What do you guys think? Do you feel as though Mrs. Ellsworth allowed Oceola to live her own life or do you think she was too controlling?
"The Blues I'm Playing"
In Langston Hughes' "The Blues I'm Playing", the protagonist lives her life at odds with her patron. The elderly white woman wants to enforce a separation of the girl from her boyfriend, the jazz community, and black culture in general in order to transplant her into the world of 'art.' The piece represents a turmoil that was occurring in the artistic community of the time- does an artist need to create in a world devoid of all else? Should rough or passionate emotions be considered part of art and key to its success, or a contaminant? During the Harlem renaissance, the rise of jazz as an American art form was at odds with classical music. The soul of jazz was in improvisation, embellishment, and change. Classical music had passion, but it was imbued in the composers notes that the musician then played to share emotion. The elderly patron looked upon classical music as art, and refused to let it share its pedestal. Her protégé was representative of the open minded youth; art was created from her and she wanted to make people feel emotions beyond the transcendental feelings her patron longed for from classical music. There is also an underlying conflict of sexuality in the piece. The piano player is happy she is not pregnant out of wedlock with her boyfriends child, and insists on marrying him later in the story. Oceola argues that she can be married, have children, and still enjoy art. The childless patron has repressed her sexuality. She channels it through her patronage of young people- some beautiful and talented, others who talent was being beautiful. There is a hint at sexual tension where Mrs. Ellsworth is lying in bed with the girl she sponsors, and the author describes her own rationalization of these feelings "... aware all the time of the electric strength of that brown-black body beside he ... then Mrs. Ellsworth would feel very motherly toward this dark girl whom she had taken under her wing on the wonderful road of art, to nurture and love until she became a great interpreter of the piano." Mrs. Ellsworth channels her sexuality under the guise of true art and patronage of those seeking it- perhaps her reasons for chastising the emotional and raw art that was the new jazz and blues stemmed from her uneasy realization that she herself had mixed sexuality with art.
Confusion and Dismay
This week the one thing I thought about would have to be the a phrase from a Langston Hughes poem which was "not a Negro poet". This phrase made me think of how hard it had to be to not want to be acknowledges as your own race because of the wealth you would not get for it back in the days. This phrase also mad em me think to myself how wrong that boy was for stating that. After reading Langston Hughes work I brainstormed how important it was to be classified under the Negro poet or author category. Although, the struggles to make it to the top as one of these professions was very hard the reward for knowing you made it despite everything that would hold you back must have been something great. I can truly say if given the opportunity i would cherish being a Negro poet or author maybe even and artist. Just because of the simple fact I despite what people may have told me to put me down rose above the influence and did what had to be done to make it somewhere in society. Another thought that has been rolling through my head for not only this week but last week as well would be the changing of ones identity (black claiming whiteness) to get a head in life through the many passages read these are the ones that touch me the most. This is because the struggle these people go through just to have the opportunity to raise their family correctly or just to have something worth having is amazing to me as a person. Would i have the courage to put a mask over my face? Would anyone in society today have the courage and lie to people even if you knew it could be unsafe? i think NOT!!!
Thursday, April 1, 2010
Identification
I was reading through some of the blogs for this week and I thought that the Harlem Renaissance is a period that I really though should be brought up this week for my blog. The two authors we read Langston Hughes and Countee Cullen both gave me to different perspectives of how blacks felt during this time. The two conflicting ideas here are whether to take pride in being black, or to try and be white with. In Langston Hughes poem, “The Negro Speaks of Rivers”, he writes as if he is proud to be black, while in Countee Cullen’s poem “Heritage”, he has a sort of feel of distance from Africa. To some degree I agree with his point of view and tone, attitude towards this because his poem was written in the 1930s at a time where his connection to Africa was very far away, so Countee Cullen really has no ties to Africa except his heritage. Countee Cullen was born in the United States and should take pride in being a black American. I definitely agree with what Emily was saying here about how she wasn’t sure whether believes that or not Countee Cullen was trying to be white, but at the same time, he does not take pride in his heritage of being Africa. I guess that is because he is not African but maybe he believes that he is a Black America. These two ideas where very controversial at this time because the black community viewed some of the people who were trying to act as though they where white as betrayers to the community but others, viewed them as individuals who are trying to make their way up the rankings in society. These topics are very touchy and hard to imagine for me because I am not black and have never experienced the type of self-identification that these authors had to do. I found it interesting how two people who are going through the same type of segregation and racial issues could have two opposite view points.
I think reading both Langston Hughes and Countee Cullen showed the contrast in ideas during the Harlem Renaissance, especially with Hughes' poem "The Negro Speaks of Rivers" and Cullen's poem "Heritage." In "The Negro Speaks of Rivers," Hughes accepts the history of blacks, he feels that it is important to acknowledge and celebrate everything black people have gone through in history. By him using "I" before every line, it is showing how he is uniting with the past and with all black people. I think if he would have used "they," it would have given the poem a sense of distance between the present and the past. Whereas in Cullen's poem, he rejects being associated with Africa. He feels that there has been too much time in between then and now to be able to connect. He does not know what Africa is, simply because he has never been there and cannot associate himself with it. In the first stanza he gives a stereotypical idea of what Africa might be like, not actually knowing if it is true or not.
I think the two poem contrast each other because while one poet, Hughes, is celebrating his heritage as an African American, they other is rejecting it. Like we read in "The Negro Artist and the Racial Mountain" by Hughes, he feels that blacks should love who they are, and appreciate their skin color instead of trying to change it or try to become more like whites. I am not sure if Cullen wants to be white or does not want to be black all together, but he really does not want associate himself with African culture. This also reminds me of "The Negro-Art Hokum" by George Samuel Schuyler because he also felt that whites and blacks are the same and that there should not be a difference because everyone is essentially the same despite the color of their skin.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)